Design Review and Feasibility Study

A fixed-scope review of an existing board and firmware, or a feasibility study for a new device, with a written report at the end.

A fixed-scope first step

A review of an existing board and its firmware, or a feasibility study for a device that does not exist yet. The scope and price are agreed before I start, and you get a written report at the end.

Ask About a Review

When it is useful

  • A device works on the bench and then fails, or flattens its battery, in the field
  • A design is about to go to fabrication or production and nobody outside the team has read it
  • A product idea depends on satellite, LoRa or long battery life, and you need to know whether it can be done and what it would take
  • A design firm needs satellite, LoRa or low power input on one part of a larger project

What I look at

Design review

For a board and firmware that already exist.

  • Power: sleep current, duty cycle and the battery budget against the life you need
  • Radio and satellite: the choice of link, message size, and airtime or cost per message
  • Firmware: structure, watchdogs, and what happens after a crash or a loss of power
  • Updates: bootloader, over-the-air update and rollback
  • Testing: what is tested now, and what could be tested on real hardware
  • Schematic and layout, where the question is about the board

Feasibility study

For a device that is still an idea.

  • Getting the data out: Iridium, LoRa, LoRaWAN or mobile data, and what each costs to run
  • Power: a first battery and solar budget for the site
  • Parts: candidate processors, radios and sensors
  • Processing: what the device should compute on board and what it should send
  • Effort: an estimate of the work to a prototype, and the main risks

What to send

  • A description of what the device does and where it will be deployed
  • Schematics and layout, if there is a board
  • The firmware source, or access to the repository
  • Any measurements you already have: current draw, signal reports, failure logs

What you get

A written report that lists what I found in order of importance and what I would change, with an estimate for any work that follows.

Where the experience comes from

  • Waves In Ice: buoys that run for months on Antarctic sea ice and report over Iridium
  • OGLAS: off-grid sensors, hubs and touch panels on LoRa
  • Zephyr RTOS: the firmware platform under both